Restaurants

Mike's Dairy Bar

4.6 131 reviews 11:00 AM - 08:00 PM 129 N Warpole St, Upper Sandusky, OH 43351, United States

Discover this place

Located in the heart of Upper Sandusky, Mike's Dairy Bar is a local gem renowned for its delicious ice cream and hearty food offerings. With glowing reviews from patrons, it’s clear that Mike’s excels in delivering a delightful dining experience. Ian McWilliams raves about the exceptional ice cream and milkshakes, calling it a must-visit for dessert lovers. Meanwhile, Sean1013 E highlights the quality of their burgers, indicating that their menu offers more than just sweet treats.

First-time visitors like D Suits are impressed not only with the food but also with the efficient and friendly service amidst a bustling atmosphere. Families flock to Mike's, and it’s no surprise that even a 220-mile drive, as Sue Graff experienced, can’t deter loyal customers from returning. However, be prepared for potential parking challenges due to its popularity.

In summary, Mike's Dairy Bar emerges as a standout destination with a vibrant menu, especially praised for its ice creams and shakes. It’s a place where food enthusiasts and families can come together, enjoy signature dishes, and create memories—making it a true cornerstone of the Upper Sandusky dining scene.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Drive-through
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Mike's Dairy Bar before visiting.

Reviews for Mike's Dairy Bar

4.6

131 reviews

100%

19%

Review highlights

Based on 131 reviews

Mike's Dairy Bar in Upper Sandusky is widely praised for its exceptional ice cream and milkshakes, which are frequently highlighted as the main draws. Customers also appreciate the quality of their burgers and overall food offerings, noting consistent satisfaction across diverse menu selections. The establishment is recognized for its efficient and friendly service, even during busy periods, contributing to a positive dining experience for families and groups. Enthusiasts often travel significant distances to return, indicating strong customer loyalty. While patrons express appreciation for the staff and atmosphere, occasional remarks about closures suggest a desire for more consistent availability. Overall, Mike's Dairy Bar maintains a reputation as a beloved local spot known for delicious treats and reliable service.

Ian McWilliams

Jun 18, 2025

Great ice cream place the ice cream is really good they have a great side cast with there milkshake amazing ice cream place come here if your carving ice cream

sean1013 E

Jun 18, 2025

I go here, they have really good burgers

D Suits

Jun 12, 2025

This was my first experience with Mike's since moving to Upper Sandusky. The place was absolutely packed and there were so many people running around the kitchen and drive through area I wad impressed with how quickly they operated as a team and still able to talk and laugh a little. I took 5 kids and everybody got something different and ALL of it was absolutely amazing. Great food, very good timely service and the only point I took off was due to the parking situation when the line wraps around the block.

Sue Graff

May 06, 2025

We liked your food so much on Thursday that we drove 220 miles to eat here again today (Monday). We were very sad that you were closed. We hope you all enjoyed your well deserved time off. We will be back.

Craig bear

May 02, 2025

Best place around to get ice cream or a shake.

Joseph Williams

Apr 29, 2025

Always a treat when we visit my mother in law. The kids love the Smurf cone. I myself stick to the twist of plain old chocolate. Either decision you can't go wrong. Great value for the money. Friendly staff.

Diana R

Apr 20, 2025

Great place to get a milkshake. I'm glad they're open again. Drive thru is very convenient.

Herb De la Porte

Mar 25, 2025

Great little ice cream place